Don’t use ‘scare quotes’

Closeup of a plaque on a park bench which reads
In loving memory of Jen and Ted South. Two of life's "nice" people
From https://old.reddit.com/r/suspiciousquotes/comments/cyqi4b/a_loving_tribute/

If you are quoting someone else in your essay you must enclose the quotation in quotation marks (although it’s often much better to remove the quotation and express the idea in your own words). And in my opinion that is the only proper use of quotation marks in essays.

Sometimes people put quotation marks around a word or a phrase to distance themselves from it, e.g.:

Michael Moore, the so-called “journalist”…

This implies that some people call Moore a journalist, but the writer wants the reader to know that she wouldn’t call him a journalist herself. It’s a rather snide construction and in my opinion it has no place in academic writing. If you don’t agree with a phrase either don’t use it at all, or state your opinion clearly and justify it. e.g.:

In my opinion, Michael Moore’s work does not match the definition of journalism because ….

Or if your tutor doesn’t allow first-person writing:

Michael Moore’s work does not match the definition of journalism because ….

Another way people sometimes use quotation marks is for emphasis. Sometimes a pub will advertise something like:

Traditional Sunday roast “beef” lunch served here

Which always makes me think they’re using scare quotes and they’re trying to say:

Some people might call it “beef”, but I wouldn’t call it that myself.

Language is always changing and although using quotation marks for emphasis is considered incorrect now, it may become normal and acceptable in future. But you just don’t need to use typography to emphasise anything in academic writing. Don’t use bold or italics or underlining or all capitals and certainly don’t use quotation marks for emphasis.

If this article didn’t answer your question, click here

Related articles

Tease Apart a Quotation Free Download

Yellow neon lights against a dark background spelling "WE CAN BE HEROES" and on the line below "JUST FOR ONE DAY"
Photo by Gabriel Bassino on Unsplash

There’s really only two occasions when it’s OK to include a quotation in an essay. The first is if you are quoting someone famous saying something in a famous way. You wouldn’t paraphrase Martin Luther King’s “I have a dream…” speech, or a line of Amanda Gorman’s poetry; you’d quote it directly. The other occasion is when you are quoting an extract of qualitative data; something said by a participant or one of the people the research is about. If you are describing research about people with disabilities, people who have experienced trauma, members of the Roma community, etc, you shouldn’t put words in their mouth but let them speak in their own words.

For everything else, you should paraphrase. Explain the ideas of textbook authors, journal article authors etc. in your words. Paraphrasing, rather than quoting, demonstrates that you understand what they meant. You should also explain why you chose these ideas to answer the question, rather than simply quoting and leaving the reader to guess why you chose that quotation.

I’ve attached a downloadable worksheet which guides you through the process of teasing apart a quotation to help you paraphrase it rather than quote it. I’ve adapted the worksheet with permission from an activity by Natalie Lancer of unicoach.org I highly recommend Natalie’s workshops for academic writing.

If this article didn’t answer your question, click here

Related articles

Writing in your own words